A
larger turbocharger will not normally create more ultimate horsepower. What the
different turbochargers do is change the rate at which the boost is created, therefore
they change the engines power curve. The larger the turbo, the more turbo lag, but
the less horsepower drop-off at high engine RPM. On the other hand...The smaller the
turbo, the less turbo lag, but the higher the horsepower drop-off at high RPM.
The
basic principle of turbocharging is that the turbocharger creates the boost, which results
in a compressed fuel mixture. Once the maximum pressure the engine can take is reached,
any excess pressure is released through the wastegate. The wastegate is a valve body that
is preset by a spring, which opens when boost pressure exceeds the spring tension. This
prevents damage to the engine from an excess boost condition. However, this
same function means a turbochargers ability to generate higher boost levels is
irrelevant as any excess boost is vented from the system.
Horsepower
in itself is not generated by the turbocharger. Examples of extremely high horsepower
rated turbo race engines, i.e. 1,100 hp in the 917/30 are a function of the engines
ability to handle a higher than "standard" boost level, which in turn is a
function of the overall engine design, quality of components, and quality of assembly.
Lets
discuss the mechanics of turbocharging. There are two ways to get "charged"
air into the combustion chamber. Turbocharging and supercharging. As compared to the
normally aspirated engine where the pistons are required to suck in the fuel mixture
through the intake stroke, the "charged" motor has this mixture forced into the
cylinder by the turbocharger or the supercharger.
Both
methods share the common goal of supplying a compressed fuel mixture into the combustion
chamber. The denser mixture results in stronger combustion and a more powerful stroke. The
turbocharger versus the supercharger has one distinct difference: While both the
turbocharger and the supercharger have a turbine wheel that compresses the intake air (cold side), the supercharger has a pulley
attached and, by means of a belt, the turbine wheel is driven off the crankshaft. The
turbocharger, rather than a pulley, has an additional turbine wheel (hot side) that is set into motion by the
exhaust gases before the exhaust gases exit through the muffler. The obvious goal is to
have the right amount of boost available at all times to produce the maximum horsepower.
Why the different size
turbochargers? Porsche uses a variety of turbo chargers including the K24, K26, K27,
K29, K31, and once there was a K36 (934 Turbo GT.) These numbers may look familiar to you.
You've probably seen them advertised as "bolt-on" improvements. The numbers
refer to the actual sizes of the fan wheels. A description of the different combinations
and there effect is as follows:
A) Small (HOT) + Small (COLD) fan wheels = a quick response but no top-end.
B) Small (HOT) + Large (COLD) fan wheels = medium response with better top-end.
C) Large (HOT) + Large (COLD) fan wheels = marginal low-end response with good top end.
The smaller the fan wheel,
the more instantaneously the necessary RPM can be obtained to make the maximum boost. In
other words, an ideal situation would be a small hot wheel and a large cold wheel. Exhaust
gases propel the small hot-wheel. Exhaust gases are a force greatly dependent on the
engines RPM, hence the nature of the compromise. At a lower RPM, the smaller hot
wheel cannot drive the larger cold wheel to create boost until a certain engine RPM is
reached. This creates turbo-lag. Turbo lag is the interval between the initiation
of acceleration and the employment of power. In extreme cases you would have no power
below 4,000 rpm and the next instant when the boost comes on full. Since the
objective is to have usable horsepower, not only at peak rpm, but also at midrange and
lower rpm, compromises in the size of both fan wheels are necessary. In a
competition motor, the issue of low-end boost is of lesser importance because racing
engines rely on a very limited high RPM range in order to create maximum horsepower.
One might be led to believe
that bigger is indeed better but dont be mislead...its not that simple.
There are physical laws to be obeyed and compromises must be made. Depending on the design
of the engine, one thing is certain: There is only so much boost an engine can absorb.
Obviously, the quality of components such as pistons, cylinders, connecting rods, etc. is
crucial. Other determining factors include compression ratio, internal cooling capability,
and the ability to dissipate heat from the cylinder head area. Turbocharging creates
horsepower, but it also creates tremendous pressure and heat. This pressure and
heat are what can destroy your motor and under extreme boost conditions, and this can take
place in seconds. Obviously, a competition motor has far superior cooling
capabilities, both air and oil, than the average street turbos. A street turbo generally
runs safely at approximately 0.7-0.8 bar boost (1 Bar = 14lbs.). A competition car
typically will run at 1.4-1.6 bar boost for short periods. The difference in boost levels
is what creates the horsepower.
With the 993 B-Turbo, the
over boost regulation is done using a wastegate which is controlled by the DME control
box. To increase the boost rate in a B-Turbo therefore, reprogramming of the DME unit is
required. The 993 B-Turbo S-version, with 430 hp vs. 408hp, is a case in point.
An ideal solution would be
to have two (twin) Turbos of a small to medium size. Porsche demonstrated this feature on
the 1986 959 model by putting two (twin) turbos in sequence, minimizing turbo-lag.
Unfortunately, to do it right was very costly, and it was decided not to incorporate this
feature into production models.
Beginning with the 993
B-Turbo, two medium sized Turbos are used. Additionally, engine size was increased,
compression was raised, and a more effective ignition and fuel injection was incorporated.
This, combined with the ratios available in a 6-speed gearbox, virtually eliminated the
turbo-lag.
There are, of course, many
enhancements that can contribute to improvements in turbocharging performance. These
include sport intercoolers with greater cooling capacity, fuel enrichment systems, and
improvements to the flow rate of the turbocharger housings.
The bottom line is this:
bigger in not necessarily better for your street turbo! Yes, there are
turbochargers that are an improvement over stock, but bolting a K-31 on your otherwise
stock-motor will do nothing for the driveability of your car despite the fact that it may
add some horsepower to the top-end of your rpm range. To achieve this top-end you will
compromise power in the low to mid-range power band and on the street this is where you
need it. When was the last time you wished you have more kick at 140 mph?
A common misconception is,
"If I get flash reading of 600 peak
horsepower on the dyno, some of it has to trickle down to my lower RPM range." It will not! We are not saying that you cant build a car that has extreme
horsepower. We are saying these cars are not intended for street use. If you have driven a
car with over 400 "street" useable horsepower, you have an appreciation of how
fast and how deadly the potential.
One of ANDIALs projects was a street car with
a motor capable of producing 700+ hp. This car was a Carrera 4 with a water cooled, twin
turbo-charged 962 engine and this engine had to be de-tuned down to 520 hp so the car
could be controlled and to ensure longevity of the power-train. Read about the car in our
Projects of Interest Section.
ANDIAL gained its knowledge of turbocharging through the development of the
racing motors tested on the toughest tracks in America, by some of the worlds
greatest drivers. We have been involved since 1976, beginning with the early 934s
and 935s. ANDIALs
credentials include 917s, 962s and the Can-am 917/30, which generated 1,100
hp.
Throughout this broad range of cars, the objective remains the same: Develop the power to match the application, and balance the dynamics of the car so that it performs to its capabilities. The game hasnt changed. The same rules of physic continue to apply.
Go Back
Copyright 1998 © ANDIAL All Rights Reserved